Top 5 Keycap Sets: Your Ultimate Buying Guide

Ever looked at your keyboard and thought, “This could be cooler?” You’re not alone! Our keyboards are more than just tools; they’re a way we express ourselves. But when it comes to picking out new keycaps, it can feel like navigating a maze. So many colors, shapes, and materials – it’s easy to get overwhelmed and wonder, “Which ones are right for *me*?”

The struggle is real! You want your keyboard to look amazing and feel great under your fingers, but the sheer number of choices can make your head spin. Do you go for bright and bold, or sleek and subtle? What about how they sound when you type? It’s a lot to think about, and sometimes it feels like you’re throwing your money away on the wrong set.

But don’t worry! By the end of this post, you’ll have a much clearer picture. We’ll break down the confusing world of keycap sets, making it easy to understand what makes a good set. You’ll learn how to choose keycaps that not only look fantastic but also feel amazing to type on, transforming your keyboard into something truly special. Get ready to upgrade your typing experience!

Our Top 5 Keycap Sets Recommendations at a Glance

Top 5 Keycap Sets Detailed Reviews

1. Womier Pudding Keycaps

Womier Pudding Keycaps, PBT Shine Through Keycaps 165 Keys Set Custom Key caps Set OEM Profile, Universal Compatiability for 100%, 75%, 65%, 60% Keyboard-Black

Rating: 8.6/10

Upgrade your keyboard with the Womier Pudding Keycaps. These black keycaps offer a unique “pudding” effect, letting your RGB lights shine through for a dazzling display. They’re made from tough PBT plastic, so they’ll last a long time. This set comes with a lot of keys, making it fit most keyboards. You also get a special box to store them in, which is super handy.

What We Like:

  • Super wide compatibility fits almost any mechanical keyboard, from big ones to small ones.
  • Made from strong PBT plastic that resists wear and tear, so they feel good and last long.
  • The “pudding” design makes your keyboard’s RGB lights look amazing and brighter.
  • The OEM profile and curved shape feel comfortable for your fingers when you type or game.
  • Comes with a cool storage box to keep your keycaps organized and safe.
  • Includes a keycap puller tool to make changing your keycaps easy.
  • The company offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, so you can buy with confidence.

What Could Be Improved:

  • If you have a very unusual keyboard layout, you might want to double-check compatibility before buying.
  • The random delivery of the storage box (canned vs. carton) might be a minor inconvenience for some.

These Womier Pudding Keycaps are a fantastic way to personalize your keyboard and enhance your gaming or typing experience. They offer great looks, comfort, and durability.

2. Womier Double Shot PBT Keycaps Set 138 Keys

Womier Double Shot PBT Keycaps Set 138 Keys, Cherry Profile Custom Keycaps 60 65 75 100 Percent for 61/64/68/84/87/100/104/108 Retro Gaming Mechanical Keyboard, Brown Gray

Rating: 9.0/10

Elevate your typing game with the Womier Double Shot PBT Keycaps Set. This 138-key set brings a touch of retro style and serious durability to your mechanical keyboard. Designed with the popular Cherry profile, these keycaps offer a comfortable and classic feel that gamers and typists alike will appreciate. The vintage brown and gray color scheme adds a cool, Gorpcore-inspired aesthetic, making your keyboard stand out.

What We Like:

  • Built tough: These keycaps use strong PBT material and a doubleshot process. This makes them last a long time. They resist getting oily, scratched, or worn out.
  • Comfy typing: The Cherry profile feels natural and comfortable. It’s a popular choice for a reason!
  • Cool vintage look: The brown and gray colors give your keyboard a retro vibe. It matches many gaming keyboards.
  • Fits most keyboards: Whether you have a 60%, 75%, or 100% keyboard, these keycaps work. They fit keyboards with 61 to 108 keys.
  • Easy to install: A keycap puller is included in the box. This makes swapping out your old keycaps simple.
  • Help is available: You can message them anytime if you have questions or issues.

What Could Be Improved:

  • Limited color options: The vintage brown and gray might not suit everyone’s taste. More color choices would be great.
  • Keycap count: While 138 keys is a lot, double-check if your specific layout needs might require additional specialized keys not included.

This Womier keycap set offers a fantastic upgrade for your mechanical keyboard, blending durability with a stylish retro look. It’s a solid choice for anyone looking to personalize their setup.

3. HyperX Pudding Keycaps – Double Shot PBT Keycap Set with Translucent Layer

HyperX Pudding Keycaps - Double Shot PBT Keycap Set with Translucent Layer, for Mechanical Keyboards, Full 104 Key Set, OEM Profile, English (US) Layout - Black

Rating: 9.0/10

Upgrade your mechanical keyboard with the HyperX Pudding Keycaps. These double shot PBT keycaps feature a unique translucent design that makes your keyboard’s RGB lighting pop. The set includes a full 104 keys in an OEM profile with an English (US) layout, all in a sleek black finish.

What We Like:

  • The translucent, dual-layer design lets your RGB lighting shine through beautifully, making your keyboard look amazing.
  • Made from durable double shot PBT material, these keycaps are built to last and resist wear and tear.
  • The bold HyperX font is easy to read and allows even more light to pass through, improving visibility.
  • A stylish keycap removal tool is included, specifically designed to fit HyperX keycaps, making installation a breeze.
  • This full key set works with HyperX and most other mechanical gaming keyboards, especially those with exposed LED switches.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The OEM profile might not be preferred by everyone; some users might favor other profiles.
  • While compatible with most mechanical keyboards, ensuring perfect fitment with every brand can sometimes be tricky.

These HyperX Pudding Keycaps offer a fantastic way to personalize your keyboard and enhance your gaming setup. They deliver on both style and durability, making them a solid choice for any mechanical keyboard enthusiast.

4. YUNZII Spring Tea Dye Sub PBT Keycaps

YUNZII Spring Tea Dye Sub PBT Keycaps,145 Full Keys Dye Sublimation PBT Custom Keycap Set with Key Puller for Cherry Gateron MX Switches Mechanical Gaming Keyboard (Cherry Profile, Spring Tea)

Rating: 9.5/10

Bring a touch of nature to your keyboard with the YUNZII Spring Tea Dye Sub PBT Keycaps. This 145-key set features a beautiful “Spring Tea” design, perfect for personalizing your mechanical keyboard. They are made from super strong PBT plastic, which means the cool designs won’t fade away with use. Plus, they feel nice and don’t get oily easily.

What We Like:

  • Super tough PBT plastic will last a long time.
  • The dye-sublimation printing makes colors bright and prevents fading.
  • The colors are water and dust resistant, which is great for keeping your keyboard clean.
  • The popular Cherry profile is comfortable for typing and gaming.
  • This set has 145 keys, so it fits almost any mechanical keyboard size.
  • It comes with a keycap puller to make swapping them out easy.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The package only includes the keycaps and a keycap puller; you’ll need your own keyboard.

If you want to give your mechanical keyboard a fresh, new look that’s built to last, the YUNZII Spring Tea Dye Sub PBT Keycaps are a fantastic choice.

5. G.SKILL Crystal Crown Keycaps – Keycap Set with Transparent Layer for Mechanical Keyboards

G.SKILL Crystal Crown Keycaps - Keycap Set with Transparent Layer for Mechanical Keyboards, Full 104 Key, Standard ANSI 104 English (US) Layout - White

Rating: 8.9/10

Brighten up your mechanical keyboard with the G.SKILL Crystal Crown Keycaps in clean White. This full 104-key set is designed to make your RGB backlighting shine like never before. It’s an easy way to give your keyboard a fresh, new look.

What We Like:

  • The clear, transparent design lets so much RGB light through. Your keyboard will look super bright and vibrant.
  • The letters on the keys are bold and easy to see. You won’t have trouble finding the right key.
  • They fit most mechanical keyboards because they work with Cherry MX stems.
  • The standard layout means they’ll fit on many different keyboards without a problem.
  • A keycap puller tool is included. This makes swapping out your old keycaps much easier.

What Could Be Improved:

  • While the transparent design is great for light, some users might prefer a more solid, opaque look for their keys.
  • The white color might show dirt or smudges more easily than darker keycaps.

If you want to boost your keyboard’s RGB and make your typing experience clearer, these G.SKILL Crystal Crown Keycaps are a fantastic upgrade. They offer a simple yet impactful way to customize your setup.

Your Guide to Awesome Keycap Sets

Your keyboard is more than just a tool; it’s a canvas for your personality! Keycap sets let you customize how your keyboard looks and feels. This guide helps you pick the perfect set.

Key Features to Look For

1. Profile

The profile is the shape and height of the keycaps. Different profiles feel different under your fingers. Some popular ones include:

  • Cherry Profile: This is a common and comfortable profile. It’s sculpted and slightly angled, making typing easy.
  • OEM Profile: Similar to Cherry, but a bit taller. Many stock keyboards use this.
  • SA Profile: These keycaps are tall and rounded. They give a retro look and a deep sound.
  • XDA Profile: These are flat and uniform in height. They offer a large surface area for your fingers.
2. Legends (What’s Printed on the Keys)

Legends are the letters, numbers, and symbols on your keycaps. How they are made matters for durability.

  • Doubleshot: Two colors of plastic are molded together. This makes legends very durable and they won’t fade.
  • Dye-Sublimation: Ink is heated and soaked into the plastic. This is also very durable.
  • Laser Etched: A laser burns the legend into the keycap. These can wear off over time.
  • Pad Printed: Ink is stamped onto the keycap. This is the least durable and can fade easily.
3. Compatibility

Make sure the keycap set fits your keyboard. Check the layout of your keyboard (like ANSI or ISO) and if it has any unusual keys (like a short Shift key or a 1.75u Ctrl key).

Important Materials

The material of your keycaps greatly affects their feel and sound. Most good keycaps use plastic. The two main types are:

1. ABS Plastic

ABS is a common plastic. It’s smooth and can develop a shine over time with use. It often produces a higher-pitched sound.

2. PBT Plastic

PBT is a tougher plastic. It feels more textured and is less likely to get shiny. PBT keycaps usually make a deeper, more satisfying sound.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Several things make keycap sets better or worse.

Quality Boosters:
  • Thick Keycaps: Thicker plastic (around 1.5mm or more) feels more solid and sounds better.
  • Precise Legends: Clear, well-aligned legends make the set look professional.
  • Consistent Color: The colors should be uniform across all keycaps.
  • Good Packaging: The keycaps should be protected so they don’t get damaged in shipping.
Quality Reducers:
  • Thin Plastic: Thin keycaps can feel flimsy and sound hollow.
  • Wobbly Legends: Legends that are blurry or misaligned look cheap.
  • Inconsistent Colors: Shades that don’t match can be distracting.
  • Poor Fit: Keycaps that don’t fit snugly on your switches can feel loose.

User Experience and Use Cases

Your choice of keycaps changes how you interact with your keyboard.

  • Typing Enthusiasts: People who type a lot often look for PBT keycaps with a comfortable profile like Cherry. They want durability and a good feel.
  • Gamers: Gamers might want brightly colored keycaps or sets with special designs. They also need durable keycaps that can handle frequent use.
  • Aesthetically Driven Users: Some people choose keycaps purely for their look. They might go for unique colorways, artistic designs, or specific themes.
  • Beginners: If you’re new to customizing, starting with a well-known profile like Cherry or OEM from a reputable brand is a good idea.

Choosing keycaps is a fun way to make your keyboard your own. Consider what matters most to you – feel, sound, durability, or looks – and you’ll find the perfect set!


Keycap Set FAQs

Q: What is the most important feature of a keycap set?

A: The most important feature depends on you. For some, it’s the profile for comfort. For others, it’s the material for durability and sound. Legends are also key for how long they last.

Q: Is PBT plastic always better than ABS?

A: PBT is generally considered higher quality because it’s more durable and feels better. However, some people prefer the smoother feel of ABS.

Q: How do I know if a keycap set will fit my keyboard?

A: Check your keyboard’s layout. Most sets list the key sizes they include. You need to make sure all your keys are covered, especially if your keyboard has a non-standard layout.

Q: What does “doubleshot” mean for keycaps?

A: Doubleshot means the legend is made from two different pieces of plastic molded together. This makes the legend very strong and it will never fade.

Q: Can keycaps change the sound of my keyboard?

A: Yes! The material, thickness, and profile of keycaps all affect the sound. Thicker PBT keycaps usually create a deeper, more satisfying sound.

Q: Are expensive keycap sets worth the money?

A: Often, yes. More expensive sets usually use better materials (like PBT), have more durable legends (like doubleshot), and are made with greater precision, leading to a better feel and look.

Q: What is a “keycap puller”?

A: A keycap puller is a tool used to safely remove keycaps from your keyboard switches without damaging them.

Q: Should I get blank keycaps if I already know how to type?

A: Blank keycaps offer a very clean and minimalist look. If you don’t need the legends to type, they can be a stylish choice.

Q: How do I clean my keycaps?

A: You can usually clean keycaps by soaking them in warm, soapy water and gently scrubbing them. Make sure they are completely dry before putting them back on.

Q: Where can I buy good keycap sets?

A: You can find keycap sets from many online retailers that specialize in mechanical keyboard parts. Popular brands and stores often sell directly on their websites.

In conclusion, every product has unique features and benefits. We hope this review helps you decide if it meets your needs. An informed choice ensures the best experience.

If you have any questions or feedback, please share them in the comments. Your input helps everyone. Thank you for reading.

Leave a Comment